| Clue | Source | Date |
|---|---|---|
| What the shocked mime would say, if he could talk? (2 wds.) | ||
| Paradoxical feedback | Newsday | 30 Jul 2022 |
| "You flabbergast me" | ||
| 'You flabbergast me' | New York Times | 31 Oct 2019 |
| Ironic exclamation of amazement | New York Times | 12 Jan 2019 |
| Ironic exclamation of amazement |