| No longer fresh | Wall Street Journal | 20 Oct 2025 | 
          
            | Like week-old bread |  |  | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Wall Street Journal | 14 Oct 2025 | 
          
            | Second story is boring (5) | The Sun Two Speed | 13 Oct 2025 | 
          
            | Old wives' tales, to some extent (5) | Puzzler Cryptic | 10 Oct 2025 | 
          
            | No longer fresh, as bread |  |  | 
          
            | No longer edible | Newsday | 05 Oct 2025 | 
          
            | Hackneyed conclusion of tedious story | The Times Quick Cryptic | 30 Sep 2025 | 
          
            | Musty (5) | Mirror Quick | 25 Sep 2025 | 
          
            | Old tales varied (5) | Mirror Cryptic | 25 Sep 2025 | 
          
            | Lacking freshness (5) | Mirror Classic | 11 Sep 2025 | 
          
            | Like crackers that have lost some crunch | New York Times Mini | 09 Sep 2025 | 
          
            | Not fresh | Commuter | 08 Sep 2025 | 
          
            | Not fresh | Commuter | 03 Sep 2025 | 
          
            | Past its best, as food | The Telegraph Mini | 31 Aug 2025 | 
          
            | Like week-old bread |  |  | 
          
            | Hard, in a way | USA Today | 10 Aug 2025 | 
          
            | Tired | New York Times | 10 Aug 2025 | 
          
            | What Jaffa Cakes can become | The Telegraph Cross Atlantic | 01 Aug 2025 | 
          
            | Timeworn | Newsday | 31 Jul 2025 | 
          
            | Opposite of fresh | Commuter | 29 Jul 2025 | 
          
            | No longer fresh | The Telegraph Cross Atlantic | 29 Jul 2025 | 
          
            | Overused | The Sun Two Speed | 25 Jul 2025 | 
          
            | Fresh loaf 's future status |  |  | 
          
            | Steal bananas? Not fresh! | The Sun Two Speed | 25 Jul 2025 | 
          
            | Like a week-old bagel | USA Today | 24 Jul 2025 | 
          
            | Last half English beer has lost its flavour (5) |  |  | 
          
            | No longer fresh | Universal | 20 Jul 2025 | 
          
            | Old, as bread |  |  | 
          
            | Trite, hackneyed | The Times Concise | 14 Jul 2025 | 
          
            | Boring | The Sun Two Speed | 14 Jul 2025 | 
          
            | Beginning of sob story hackneyed | The Sun Two Speed | 14 Jul 2025 | 
          
            | Not fresh | Commuter | 14 Jul 2025 | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Thomas Joseph | 09 Jul 2025 | 
          
            | Unlike fresh bread |  |  | 
          
            | Overused | The Sun Two Speed | 16 Jun 2025 | 
          
            | Second yarn boring | The Sun Two Speed | 16 Jun 2025 | 
          
            | Timeworn | Newsday | 15 Jun 2025 | 
          
            | No longer fresh | Thomas Joseph | 09 Jun 2025 | 
          
            | Left out overnight, maybe | LA Times Daily | 07 Jun 2025 | 
          
            | No longer a novelty |  |  | 
          
            | No longer fresh, as bread | Newsday | 02 Jun 2025 | 
          
            | No longer fresh, as rolls | Newsday | 26 May 2025 | 
          
            | Fresh no longer |  |  | 
          
            | Like old jokes and old bread | USA Today | 18 May 2025 | 
          
            | Least liquid is past its best (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Tales is far from fresh ... (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Not fresh | Mirror Tea Time | 28 Apr 2025 | 
          
            | 8 are not fresh (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Like old pizza | Universal | 25 Apr 2025 | 
          
            | Far from fresh | New York Times | 24 Apr 2025 | 
          
            | Like cookies that were left out for too long, maybe |  |  | 
          
            | Not fresh | Commuter | 22 Apr 2025 | 
          
            | Old, as food | The Telegraph Plusword | 21 Apr 2025 | 
          
            | Hardly original | LA Times Daily | 20 Apr 2025 | 
          
            | Least likely to be off (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Saint gets drink that's not fresh |  |  | 
          
            | Old, musty |  |  | 
          
            | At most half the beer is flat (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Like crackers after the box is left open | New York Times Mini | 28 Mar 2025 | 
          
            | Like a rock-hard baguette | USA Today | 25 Mar 2025 | 
          
            | Lacking freshness | Mirror Classic | 24 Mar 2025 | 
          
            | Like week-old bread |  |  | 
          
            | 11 is far from fresh... (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Unimaginative opening of short story (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Hackneyed opening in short story (5) | The Guardian Quiptic | 23 Feb 2025 | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Wall Street Journal | 13 Feb 2025 | 
          
            | Played out | LA Times Daily | 11 Feb 2025 | 
          
            | Uninspired | LA Times Daily | 08 Feb 2025 | 
          
            | Small lie is off |  |  | 
          
            | Cliched | LA Times Daily | 06 Feb 2025 | 
          
            | Not fresh: - bread |  |  | 
          
            | Days-old |  |  | 
          
            | Small story rehashed (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Like the bread that's a couple of days old? |  |  | 
          
            | Like old potato chips |  |  | 
          
            | Old tales varied | Mirror Cryptic | 21 Dec 2024 | 
          
            | Musty | Mirror Quick | 21 Dec 2024 | 
          
            | Spielberg's West Side Story is hackneyed |  |  | 
          
            | Out of practice | Newsday | 12 Dec 2024 | 
          
            | Like bread that's been out too long? | The Telegraph Plusword | 10 Dec 2024 | 
          
            | Old tales rewritten (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Like many a dad joke | New York Times | 23 Nov 2024 | 
          
            | Overused | The Sun Two Speed | 22 Nov 2024 | 
          
            | Steal bananas? Not fresh! | The Sun Two Speed | 22 Nov 2024 | 
          
            | Way beer becomes less fresh (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Overused story following saint primarily (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Polar story heard too often? (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Second yarn hackneyed | The Sun Two Speed | 06 Nov 2024 | 
          
            | Overused | The Sun Two Speed | 06 Nov 2024 | 
          
            | Like week-old bread |  |  | 
          
            | Like bread used for stuffing, perhaps |  |  | 
          
            | No longer fresh | Commuter | 01 Nov 2024 | 
          
            | Old rickety seat the pupil is occupying (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Beginning of sob story tired | The Sun Two Speed | 29 Oct 2024 | 
          
            | Overused | The Sun Two Speed | 29 Oct 2024 | 
          
            | Mot fresh anymore |  |  | 
          
            | Like month-old cake | USA Today | 26 Oct 2024 | 
          
            | Like old cereal |  |  | 
          
            | Like old bread |  |  | 
          
            | Like old jokes | Universal | 22 Oct 2024 | 
          
            | Flat, like beer |  |  | 
          
            | Like jokes you've heard ten times already |  |  | 
          
            | Threadbare, trite (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Like week-old injera. probably | USA Today | 15 Oct 2024 | 
          
            | Second story is a bit old (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Outdated tales varied | Mirror Cryptic | 10 Oct 2024 | 
          
            | Musty | Mirror Quick | 10 Oct 2024 | 
          
            | Second story is boring | The Sun Two Speed | 10 Oct 2024 | 
          
            | No longer fresh | The Sun Two Speed | 10 Oct 2024 | 
          
            | Left in the seat to be mended. It's old (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Overused and uncreative | New York Times | 30 Sep 2024 | 
          
            | Not fresh | Universal | 30 Sep 2024 | 
          
            | Not fresh (of bread) (5) |  |  | 
          
            | The old chalet's finally demolished (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Thomas Joseph | 23 Sep 2024 | 
          
            | Dry, as bread |  |  | 
          
            | Not fresh | The Telegraph Cross Atlantic | 18 Sep 2024 | 
          
            | Like a cliched piece of writing or an old piece of bread |  |  | 
          
            | Old, initially sad story |  |  | 
          
            | Old tales re-edited |  |  | 
          
            | Like old bread |  |  | 
          
            | Like day-old bread | Commuter | 10 Sep 2024 | 
          
            | Like week-old naan | USA Today | 10 Sep 2024 | 
          
            | Like week-old noon |  |  | 
          
            | Like bread ready to be used in stuffing |  |  | 
          
            | Steal liquid no longer fresh (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Beginning of sob story hackneyed | The Sun Two Speed | 30 Aug 2024 | 
          
            | Overused | The Sun Two Speed | 30 Aug 2024 | 
          
            | Old, lacking freshness (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Overused | The Sun Two Speed | 26 Aug 2024 | 
          
            | Good fellow with beer not fresh | The Sun Two Speed | 26 Aug 2024 | 
          
            | Overused | The Sun Two Speed | 23 Aug 2024 | 
          
            | Second yarn boring | The Sun Two Speed | 23 Aug 2024 | 
          
            | So, so overused | USA Today | 18 Aug 2024 | 
          
            | Like bread that's gone bad |  |  | 
          
            | Day-old |  |  | 
          
            | Not fresh | The Telegraph Plusword | 09 Aug 2024 | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Thomas Joseph | 06 Aug 2024 | 
          
            | Second story got old | Mirror Cryptic | 25 Jul 2024 | 
          
            | Musty | Mirror Quick | 25 Jul 2024 | 
          
            | Tired | New York Times | 19 Jul 2024 | 
          
            | Like moldy bread |  |  | 
          
            | Not fresh, as bread | The Telegraph Cross Atlantic | 17 Jul 2024 | 
          
            | Far from fresh | Wall Street Journal | 06 Jul 2024 | 
          
            | Least fresh? Not fresh at all |  |  | 
          
            | Not fresh | The Telegraph Plusword | 27 Jun 2024 | 
          
            | Not fresh | Commuter | 27 Jun 2024 | 
          
            | Although there's a point to the story, it's trite (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Not new in the least! |  |  | 
          
            | Like an old bagel |  |  | 
          
            | Like bread for stuffing | LA Times Daily | 12 Jun 2024 | 
          
            | Not fresh | Mirror Tea Time | 08 Jun 2024 | 
          
            | Not fresh; least (anag.) | The Telegraph Mini | 27 May 2024 | 
          
            | Fusty |  |  | 
          
            | Like food that's no longer fresh ...or a hint to solve 19a, 33a, 44a, 15d, and 43d |  |  | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Wall Street Journal | 23 May 2024 | 
          
            | Not fresh | Commuter | 21 May 2024 | 
          
            | Old and funny tales (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Like hard bread | USA Today | 17 May 2024 | 
          
            | Opposite of fresh | Commuter | 13 May 2024 | 
          
            | The opposite of fresh |  |  | 
          
            | For a second time, drink was past its best (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Hard, unfresh (bread) (5) |  |  | 
          
            | No longer fresh, as old bread |  |  | 
          
            | Past the shelf date |  |  | 
          
            | Unfresh (5) |  |  | 
          
            | At least I'm not fresh! (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Not fresh, as bread | Newsday | 15 Apr 2024 | 
          
            | Musty | Mirror Quick | 11 Apr 2024 | 
          
            | Old tales are translated | Mirror Cryptic | 11 Apr 2024 | 
          
            | Not at all fresh |  |  | 
          
            | Like cut-rate bread |  |  | 
          
            | Some of his talent is no longer fresh (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Like old French bread |  |  | 
          
            | Off, least off (5) | Puzzler Cryptic | 30 Mar 2024 | 
          
            | Like week-old bread |  |  | 
          
            | Second story was past its best (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Least likely to order what's off (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Old tales improved | Mirror Cryptic | 01 Mar 2024 | 
          
            | Musty | Mirror Quick | 01 Mar 2024 | 
          
            | Least (anag.) (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Like chips that have been out for too long |  |  | 
          
            | No longer fresh or pleasant to eat (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Hackneyed, tired (5) |  |  | 
          
            | Musty | Mirror Quick | 01 Feb 2024 | 
          
            | New tales got old | Mirror Cryptic | 01 Feb 2024 | 
          
            | Not fresh | Mirror Tea Time | 28 Jan 2024 | 
          
            | No longer fresh | Thomas Joseph | 15 Jan 2024 | 
          
            | Like bread past its use-by date |  |  | 
          
            | Lacking freshness | Mirror Classic | 09 Jan 2024 | 
          
            | Like jokes you've heard umpteen times before |  |  | 
          
            | Hard, like an old bagel |  |  | 
          
            | Old tales get translated | Mirror Cryptic | 16 Dec 2023 | 
          
            | Musty | Mirror Quick | 16 Dec 2023 | 
          
            | No longer fresh | The Sun Two Speed | 10 Dec 2023 | 
          
            | Second story is boring | The Sun Two Speed | 10 Dec 2023 | 
          
            | Like old bread | Universal | 07 Dec 2023 | 
          
            | Not fresh anymore | Newsday | 05 Dec 2023 | 
          
            | Trite | LA Times Mini | 27 Nov 2023 | 
          
            | Far from fresh | LA Times Daily | 08 Nov 2023 | 
          
            | Not fresh, as bread | Newsday | 06 Nov 2023 | 
          
            | Lacking creativity | New York Times | 21 Oct 2023 | 
          
            | No longer edible | Newsday | 10 Oct 2023 | 
          
            | No longer fresh | Newsday | 17 Sep 2023 | 
          
            | Overused | LA Times Daily | 01 Sep 2023 | 
          
            | Like bread for French toast, ideally | Universal | 25 Aug 2023 | 
          
            | Musty, as air | Wall Street Journal | 19 Aug 2023 | 
          
            | Shopworn | Thomas Joseph | 25 Jul 2023 | 
          
            | Like a rock-hard roll | Universal | 22 Jul 2023 | 
          
            | Like moldy bread |  |  | 
          
            | Trite | Eugene Sheffer | 26 Jun 2023 | 
          
            | Past its use-by date, maybe | Wall Street Journal | 26 Jun 2023 | 
          
            | Outdated, as a slice of bread |  |  | 
          
            | Like an old doughnut | Universal | 05 Jun 2023 | 
          
            | Like bread that's no longer fresh |  |  | 
          
            | Not fresh, as bread | Newsday | 16 May 2023 | 
          
            | Like old bread |  |  | 
          
            | Not fresh, as bread | Newsday | 02 May 2023 | 
          
            | Flat, as cola | Premier Sunday | 23 Apr 2023 | 
          
            | Like week-old bread |  |  | 
          
            | Played out | Newsday | 13 Apr 2023 | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Thomas Joseph | 29 Mar 2023 | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Thomas Joseph | 08 Feb 2023 | 
          
            | Like yesterday's xiaolongbao | USA Today | 01 Feb 2023 | 
          
            | No longer novel | LA Times Daily | 22 Jan 2023 | 
          
            | No longer fresh, as rolls | Newsday | 23 Nov 2022 | 
          
            | Bread suitable to make croutons |  |  | 
          
            | Like April's bread in June | Family Time | 13 Nov 2022 | 
          
            | Trite | Eugene Sheffer | 02 Nov 2022 | 
          
            | Not fresh, as bread | Newsday | 31 Oct 2022 | 
          
            | Like some unpleasant air | New York Times | 07 Oct 2022 | 
          
            | No longer fresh, as bread | Newsday | 05 Oct 2022 | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Thomas Joseph | 13 Aug 2022 | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Thomas Joseph | 28 Jul 2022 | 
          
            | Like week-old bagels | Wall Street Journal | 25 Jul 2022 | 
          
            | Like moldy bread |  |  | 
          
            | Lose its spark, as a relationship | New York Times | 19 Jun 2022 | 
          
            | Like day-old donuts |  |  | 
          
            | Past its best | Thomas Joseph | 06 May 2022 | 
          
            | Like hard bread | Universal | 23 Apr 2022 | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Thomas Joseph | 22 Apr 2022 | 
          
            | Like month-old bread | USA Today | 14 Apr 2022 | 
          
            | Not fresh, as bread | Newsday | 13 Apr 2022 | 
          
            | Like old bread | USA Today | 08 Apr 2022 | 
          
            | Like the bread in stuffing | USA Today | 29 Mar 2022 | 
          
            | No longer fresh | USA Today | 28 Mar 2022 | 
          
            | No longer fresh, as bread | Newsday | 22 Mar 2022 | 
          
            | No longer edible | Newsday | 02 Mar 2022 | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Thomas Joseph | 23 Feb 2022 | 
          
            | Past its use-by date | Wall Street Journal | 14 Feb 2022 | 
          
            | No longer fresh, as bread | Newsday | 07 Feb 2022 | 
          
            | Like old baozi | USA Today | 01 Feb 2022 | 
          
            | Like last night's leftovers |  |  | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Thomas Joseph | 12 Jan 2022 | 
          
            | Like bread past its use-by date |  |  | 
          
            | Like yesterday’s doughnuts | Wall Street Journal | 04 Jan 2022 | 
          
            | Like old bread |  |  | 
          
            | Like old bread | USA Today | 20 Dec 2021 | 
          
            | Not fresh | Universal | 08 Dec 2021 | 
          
            | Like old bread |  |  | 
          
            | Mouldy | The Telegraph Quick | 11 Nov 2021 | 
          
            | Like hard bagels | The Washington Post Sunday | 07 Nov 2021 | 
          
            | Not fresh | The Telegraph Quick | 07 Nov 2021 | 
          
            | Like old bread | USA Today | 30 Oct 2021 | 
          
            | Past its best | Thomas Joseph | 20 Oct 2021 | 
          
            | Trite | Eugene Sheffer | 18 Oct 2021 | 
          
            | Like old donuts | USA Today | 08 Oct 2021 | 
          
            | No longer fresh | Thomas Joseph | 04 Oct 2021 | 
          
            | Old hat | The Washington Post | 02 Oct 2021 | 
          
            | Old hat | LA Times Daily | 02 Oct 2021 | 
          
            | Like old bread | USA Today | 25 Sep 2021 | 
          
            | Like old bread | Universal | 19 Sep 2021 | 
          
            | Like day-old mantou, probably | USA Today | 12 Sep 2021 | 
          
            | Flat | LA Times Daily | 01 Sep 2021 | 
          
            | Flat | The Washington Post | 01 Sep 2021 | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Thomas Joseph | 24 Aug 2021 | 
          
            | No longer edible | Newsday | 18 Aug 2021 | 
          
            | No longer fresh, as bread | Newsday | 10 Aug 2021 | 
          
            | Not fresh anymore | USA Today | 31 Jul 2021 | 
          
            | Hardly new | LA Times Daily | 11 Jul 2021 | 
          
            | Hardly new | The Washington Post | 11 Jul 2021 | 
          
            | Not fresh anymore | USA Today | 10 Jul 2021 | 
          
            | Old and hard to eat | USA Today | 02 Jul 2021 | 
          
            | Shopworn | Thomas Joseph | 25 Jun 2021 | 
          
            | Like old pizza | Universal | 05 Jun 2021 | 
          
            | Like April's bread in June | Family Time | 30 May 2021 | 
          
            | No longer fresh, as bread | Newsday | 24 May 2021 | 
          
            | Mouldy | The Telegraph Quick | 29 Apr 2021 | 
          
            | Like an old joke | LA Times Daily | 28 Apr 2021 | 
          
            | Like an old joke | The Washington Post | 28 Apr 2021 | 
          
            | Like many dad jokes | LA Times Daily | 16 Apr 2021 | 
          
            | Like many dad jokes | The Washington Post | 16 Apr 2021 | 
          
            | Hardly original | Wall Street Journal | 03 Apr 2021 | 
          
            | Like old jokes | Universal | 25 Mar 2021 | 
          
            | Not fresh, as bread | Newsday | 15 Mar 2021 | 
          
            | Storyteller's first yarn lacking originality | The Telegraph Cryptic | 25 Feb 2021 | 
          
            | Out of practice | Newsday | 21 Feb 2021 | 
          
            | Past its best | Thomas Joseph | 12 Feb 2021 | 
          
            | Like bread used for stuffing | USA Today | 07 Feb 2021 | 
          
            | No longer exciting | USA Today | 20 Jan 2021 | 
          
            | Second story is boring |  |  | 
          
            | Second story, no longer new |  |  | 
          
            | Not fresh | The Telegraph Quick | 08 Dec 2020 | 
          
            | Trite | Eugene Sheffer | 24 Nov 2020 | 
          
            | Hackneyed | Thomas Joseph | 11 Nov 2020 | 
          
            | No longer fresh |  |  | 
          
            | Like hard rolls | The Washington Post Sunday | 13 Sep 2020 | 
          
            | Food unfit to eat |  |  | 
          
            | Like old bread | USA Today | 15 Aug 2020 | 
          
            | Second story is insipid | The Telegraph Toughie | 29 Jul 2020 | 
          
            | No longer edible | Newsday | 23 Jul 2020 | 
          
            | Like bread used for stuffing, often | New York Times | 21 Jul 2020 | 
          
            | Food that is no longer fresh |  |  | 
          
            | No longer fresh, as old bread | Newsday | 13 Jul 2020 | 
          
            | Far from original | Wall Street Journal | 08 Jul 2020 | 
          
            | Clichéd | The Washington Post | 10 Jun 2020 | 
          
            | Clichéd | LA Times Daily | 10 Jun 2020 | 
          
            | Uninspired by Dickens' last work of fiction? |  |  | 
          
            | No longer fresh | USA Today | 04 May 2020 | 
          
            | Antonym of "fresh" |  |  | 
          
            | Timeworn | Newsday | 08 Mar 2020 | 
          
            | Tired of Street-Porter? |  |  | 
          
            | Well past its prime | The Washington Post | 19 Jan 2020 | 
          
            | Well past its prime | LA Times Daily | 19 Jan 2020 | 
          
            | Boringly familiar | Canadiana | 06 Jan 2020 | 
          
            | Like week-old bread |  |  | 
          
            | Good fellow on the beer becoming overfamiliar |  |  | 
          
            | No longer fresh |  |  | 
          
            | Food that is far from fresh |  |  | 
          
            | Food that's lived too long |  |  | 
          
            | When something is old or outdated, as with bread |  |  | 
          
            | Antonym of fresh |  |  | 
          
            | Second pork pie, minimal |  |  | 
          
            | Old table top found amongst discounted items |  |  | 
          
            | Old? Makes least difference |  |  | 
          
            | Least worried about flat |  |  | 
          
            | Beginning of sob story, hackneyed |  |  | 
          
            | Uninteresting second report |  |  | 
          
            | Tired nation has left for the second time |  |  | 
          
            | Unoriginal opening to short story |  |  |